Judge my books by their covers
I need your help with some customer feedback
Please judge my books by their covers
Yes, really. I’m asking you to do the thing we’re always told not to do.
I’m running a small experiment with the covers of my two novels, War Inc. and Ten Pound Note, and I’d love your help. Especially if you haven’t read them and don’t know what they’re about.
Before I explain why, take a quick look at the covers below. Give each one a few seconds, roughly the attention you might give a book while browsing.

For each book:
What kind of story would you expect?
What tone does the cover suggest?
Would you click to read the description? Why, or why not?
Does it remind you of any other books or authors?
There are no correct answers to work out. I want your first impression, even if it’s “I have absolutely no idea”.
Please send your answers privately through my website contact form or a DM message, ideally before reading anyone else’s responses. Tell me which cover you’re discussing and what you normally enjoy reading.
If you already know the books, perhaps you could share this with a reader who doesn’t.
Why am I doing this?
Writing a book and persuading someone to give it a chance are two very different challenges.
I’ve spent a lot of time on the first. Recently, I’ve been taking a closer look at the second: how people discover my books, what makes them stop scrolling, and what might persuade them to read the description.
Some Amazon advertising has produced a small amount of buying and reading activity, but the results haven’t justified the spending. I’ve paused the campaigns while I examine the whole journey, from the audience seeing an advert to the page they reach after clicking.
The cover is one part of that journey.
That doesn’t mean I’ve established that either cover is causing a problem. I haven’t. But before I spend more on advertising, or consider changing the artwork, I want to understand what the existing covers communicate.
A cover makes a promise
When we browse for books, we have very little information to work with.
An image, a title, an author’s name. Perhaps a rating or a line of description. From those few clues, we start forming expectations about the story inside.
Is it likely to be funny? Serious? Romantic? Violent? Something familiar, or something unusual?
A cover can catch someone’s eye and still leave them expecting a different kind of book. Equally, it might communicate the story perfectly well to readers who enjoy that sort of fiction, while leaving other people unmoved.
That’s why I’m interested in what you expect to find inside, alongside whether the artwork appeals to you.
I’m too close to these books
I know the characters, the stories and the reasons behind the cover designs. When I look at either cover, I bring all of that knowledge with me.
Someone encountering it for the first time has none of it.
I can’t give myself that first encounter again. You can give me something much closer to it.
I’m deliberately leaving the plots and genres out of this post because explaining them first would influence your answers. Once you know what a book is meant to be, it becomes much harder to say what you would have assumed.
What happens next?
I’ll look for patterns in the responses.
Do several people expect a similar kind of story? Are the reactions different among readers with different tastes? Is there something people consistently find intriguing or confusing?
A small, informal exercise won’t tell me whether a redesign would increase sales. It can help me identify questions worth investigating before making that decision.
I may discover that a cover needs attention. I may find that the covers are doing their job and my effort belongs elsewhere. Either result would be useful.
So, for once, please judge my books by their covers.
Just tell me what you think is inside.