← Back to Reading
    Dungeon Crawler Carl

    Dungeon Crawler Carl

    by Matt Dinniman

    Fantasy, Sci-Fi, Craziness

    Finished: 18 November 2026

    "A dungeon crawling rampage with Carl & Donut"

    This review might sound to you like it’s a touch inconsistent, and thats because it is. But bear with me, there is a lot to unpack with this book. At various points I loved it, got bored, thought about abandoning and now think I will read the second book as my next read. As you can tell, it’s been a rollercoaster!

    The premise is just mad. An alien race destroys nearly all life on earth in an instant and turns the planet into the set for an intergalactic TV show where the contestants (survivors of the destruction) have to battle their way through a monster infested dungeon, gaining abilities, skills and levelling up as they go. The titular hero is Carl, a nobody who just happened to be standing outside his apartment in his boxers and no shoes trying to get his ex-girlfriend’s cat when the world was destroyed. He and the cat ended up in the dungeon and now the two of them are a team (the cat can now talk) that is slowly working its way through the nightmare.

    I loved the premise, and the execution of it for the first third of the book was great. The setup was slick, the explanation of the situation was efficient and effective and I was there with Carl and I understood the mission. However, it felt to me like the setup was laboured and the middle third of the book was very repetitive. Find new monster, fight monster, beat monster, get new stuff, move on, find new monster. Rinse and repeat.

    It was only in the last third that the hint of more going on behind the scenes became apparent and the mystery behind the game started to be revealed. In my opinion this could have come sooner. But now it has been revealed the book ends at a point where I want to know more. Hence I think I will break my unwritten rule and read book number two next.

    I gave it a 4 star because of that lull in the middle but it was still a very enjoyable read. I loved the characters, Carl and Donut are great. I would recommend if you like a book that is batshit crazy and a rip-roaring adventure.