
The Bone Clocks
by David Mitchell
Finished: 29 October 2026
"Beautifully written but looses its way"
I really wanted to love this book. It was so beautifully written with such wonderful details and touches and by an author whose books I have enjoyed in the past. Yet despite enjoying it and despite getting to the end of a pretty long book in just a few days, it did leave me somewhat disappointed. I have a documented checklist that I use for my rating to ensure some level of consistency, and one of the key elements that I am clinging to was “I am glad I finished reading it” and thats very true. I won’t be reading it again though.
The book is loosely about a war between two types of people who are able to live forever through a couple of different methods. One of these sets at the goodies, the Horologists, the others are the baddies, the Anchorites. As you would expect then, there is a fair bit of thirst and parry between these two factions that occur across many time periods and involve a host of fantastical capabilities.
Yet the book felt to me like three distinct stories bolted together with the thread of the premise being present, to a greater or lesser extent, in each.
We have a set of related stories of Holly, Hugo, Ed and Crispin. Then we move on to the war itself, the combatants become more front and centre, their backstories and journeys to the big battle explored. And finally there is a short story about a post apocalyptic world where society is crumbling and the world has gone to ruin.
Each of these parts of the book are interesting and enjoyable to read but I was hoping that things would be wrapped up and brought together more than they are. Loose ends remain loose, questions remain unanswered and I felt slightly unfulfilled by the end.
I love David Mitchells writing style, his imagery and use of words is something to behold, but this book fell flat for me.
Shout out for the stunning cover though, what a beauty!